the No.1 Ladies' Detective agency

5 posts / 0 new
Last post
the No.1 Ladies' Detective agency

by Alexander McCall Smith.

Fantastic book. Just read the first one closely followed by the sequel called Tears of the Giraffe.

gail
Anonymous's picture
I mentioned this book before on Liana's "need something badly" thread but I felt it was so good it deserved a thread all of its own!!
Tony Cook
Anonymous's picture
I quite enjoyed it. It just seemed a bit simplistic and possibly patronising. the stereotype of the enormous black woman roaming around dispensing good in a 'kooky' style just seemed a touch Hollywood. However I would concede that it is reasonably well written and has a gently satisfying plot but I must admit to passing the sequel by...
gail
Anonymous's picture
I was thinking in some ways it was like a children's book, I guess because it has that simplicity, I guess I like simplicity!
Rachel
Anonymous's picture
I enjoyed it but the editing is terrible! A mistake on nearly every page and a few glaring plot errors. Have got tears of giraffe but my sister says that's even worse for spelling and continuity bloopers - I'm too anal to read it without getting irritated.
Topic locked