Anamysztike - Enzo

10 posts / 0 new
Last post
Anamysztike - Enzo

http://www.abctales.com/story/enzo-v2-0/anamysztike-1-westerly-to-bath

I wanted to flag this up because I think it is very good. There are several reasons for this. Most of them involve the deft writing style, the original way in which ideas are expressed, the deadpan humour, the way that hints at what may come are dotted, subtly, through the piece. Also, the quiet menace or threat that something terrible might happen.

The idea of a narrator following car numberplates, following words that appeal to him, is really good. Original. It sort of made me want to do it. Like shaking a dice, but much better.

'And if I liked the word, I would follow the car. Sometimes I'd do that for hours. One time, I ended up in Bath, which is about 110 miles from London. It was because of the number plate X721 WSL, which became 'westerly'. And it was west that I headed, following the number plate and following the word.'

This sets up lots of potential themes for the rest of the book - how the lead character is taken by things, on a seeming whim (same of his reaction to the name and face of Anamysztike)...that he has no set place he belongs, that he is 'looking' for something...

This works in simple things too, like 'Later that day I stood at the foot of the Corcovado Mountain and looked up at the outstretched arms of Christ the Redeemer. I'd had enough.'

or 'My mother lived for less than fifty-five years, despite being born almost a century after Gustav Lindenthal, in an age of pharmaceuticals and scans and radiotherapy,'

I also like the assides, which say a lot about the narrator and his interests and temperament, such as 'Synonyms of 'commiserations' include 'bad luck' and 'nevermind' and 'better luck next time'. I like it.

It is all very taut, precise, with a hint of promise. There is enough intrigue to make the reader read on. I want to read on.

The way this is written makes me a) want to know where his whims will take him b) what the hints about 'redemption' are about - does he need to be redeemed? c) will he meet Anamysztike, d) think about the religious stuff.. the narrator says he has no religious background, but there are various religious images, concepts in this chapter, and the tension between this works well and e) What will happen with Olga? Because the narrator lets his decisions happen for him, this sets up the idea that anything might happen.

Stylewise, I would consider taking out a couple of extraneous things, such as:

'That lesson was not there to be learned at my mother's funeral.' - that was implied by what came previously, and I think it is more powerful without.

'she said angrily' - take out angrily... her words tell us she's angry, and saying she's angry takes the force out of it. Also, because Olga is such an intriguiing character just having her say that stuff makes it interesting... maybe she's angry, maybe she's playing... the reader can make up his/her own mind.

I think I said before I'd take out the word paedophile.... I like that setence better if she just said, 'He's playing Humbert Humbert,' instead. It just sounds more like something someone might say, and Olga doesn't strike me as someone who would explain herself.

I would have to read the rest to know whether the stylistic thing of having little chunks would work in a novel - I found it fine here, in fact I found it held my interest and I liked the way that worked - but it might be hard to continue over 65,000 words...

All in all, top drawer, well written, original and cherry worthy, methinks.

Enzo v2.0
Anonymous's picture
I can't thank you enough for going into so much detail here, Hayley, it's just what I need. Yes, 'paedophile' will go and 'angrily' will certainly go (and I'm usually so well behaved with adverbs!). What's great about your comments is that they all ask the questions I didn't think would occur to a reader at this point, but all questions I *want* to raise. Thanks again Ben
Foster
Anonymous's picture
Ben, I just emailed you my critique, which has nothing to do with content, but rather style - and merely suggestions, at that. I thought the story was amazing and there's nothing I can say except that, like Fergal, I'm ready to read on. A few of the suggestions I pointed out were also pointed out above, which made me feel a little better about suggesting them. To post them here wouldn't have worked very well - I don't think my suggestions would have made much sense if taken out of the context of the story. They may not anyway, just as that explanation doesn't make much sense. foster
Enzo v2.0
Anonymous's picture
Just for the record, as it deserves to be commented on, what Foster has sent me is a word document, in which he's used track changes to make comments directly against what I've written. Not only must this have taken him a long time, but also the suggestions he has given are, without exception, spot on. Amidst all the arguments about crit and so on on other threads, I just wanted to flag that up. Thanks Foster.
That is a super-tight first chapter. Really good choice of what details to focus on and, just as importantly, which to leave out. One quibble - I've only crossed the Atlantic once (well, twice - I came back) but from that height I don't believe the water would appear to be rushing by. The distance means it seems to roll by very slowly, like when you look at far off hills out a car window. But otherwise, proper tight. I am convinced.
Enzo v2.0
Anonymous's picture
Tidied up as per The Ferg's and Foster's suggestions - very much appreciated.
Enzo v2.0
Anonymous's picture
Cheers Rokkit. I like rushed, but you're right, it's probably the wrong word. I'll come up with something...
Foster
Anonymous's picture
Like Tim said, this reads really tight now. Also, I didn’t email the crit because I thought Ben would be offended if I posted it – not at all. I just didn’t want to fill the forum with numerous lines of: “You said ______ and I think it might sound better if you said ______” I think the email approach worked well (for a longer piece like this one) - Ben’s good enough to choose the suggestions that fit, as he knows best what he’s trying to do, and discard the rest. Foster.
Hey Ben, I really enjoyed this. I think the crits so far have been great so I'll just say I'm looking forward to reading more. Good job the second chapter's already up. Thanks! Joe
Enzo v2.0
Anonymous's picture
Cheers Joe, and thanks to Tony for the story of the week, it really means a lot with this piece.
Topic locked