One Nation - Aye right! What planet are you living on pal?

download

I met Scott Halley on my way up Singers Road. I assumed he’d been to the polling station. But he told me he didn’t bother. I know a lot of people that don’t bother. I can’t say I blame them. We live in a more-it-tocracy. The more you have the more you expect and the more you get, whether it’s wealth, jobs, health, or education. For the poor politics is something done to you. When you expect nothing and get nothing there are no surprises. That’s what governments do, give you less and less and expect you to stretch it more and more. More-it-tocracy is the politics of the rich.

The big losers in the election were the Labour Party. Alex Salmond called their bluff saying when you make an ally of the Tory Party, as they did in the referendum, and wear the same clothes, people often find it difficult to tell them apart. Ask Clegg and the Liberal Party. The truth is, apart from Trident, there’s not a lot of difference between SNP policies and New Labours. The big difference is SNP haven’t betrayed us – yet, because they haven’t been in the position to do so. We expect the Tory party to do what they do, give money to the rich, take money from the poor, dismantle the welfare state. It’s a tick list and they’re working their way down it.

As Neil Kinnock said of Thatcherism before losing the election to John Major: ‘I warn you not to be ordinary; I warn you not to be young; I warn you not to fall ill; I warn you not to get old’.

Labours biggest fault (well apart from making an ally of David Cameron) was not challenging the Tory lies about the need to bring down the deficit. Historically money at practically zero percent interest has never been so cheap. Apple, by share price and profits, one of the most successful company in corporate history has debt because it’s cheaper to borrow and spend on physical and social capital than just spend. It’s called investing in the future. That well known socialist institution The International Monetary Fund said much the same thing.

Why did we believe this great lie? Well for one thing the 2008 crash happened on Labour’s watch. And although they made noises about what the Tory cuts were doing to society it was too little and too late. Haunted by a past defeat to John Major, when most electoral polls put Labour ahead, the party blamed the electorate for not being able to stomach what was then a modest increase in taxation. The electoral success of Blair and Brown in agreeing to Tory fiscal constraints before being elected was a straitjacket Ed Miliband wore with pride. He was even pictured with it written in stone. They should bury him under it. Labour like the Liberal Party is finished. It’s the equivalent of the Berlin Wall falling. The choices in England are Conservative or Tory? Tory or Conservative? With less than twenty percent of the popular vote they lord it over the United Kingdom.

The Scottish National Party for whom I voted with fifty-two percent of the popular vote in Scotland and 56 of 59 seats is the winner. When Osborne dismantles the welfare state and hollows out the rights of workers and reduces those on benefits to rations and foodbanks that no modern European country, or its citizens, would find tolerable, Salmond can smugly say I told you so. But he can do nothing about it. Win win for him and SNP. Lose, lose for those on less than £100 000 a year.

History is when we’re doomed to make the same mistakes. After the Scottish referendum was lost in 1979 Labour were called the ‘feeble fifty’ because over fifty Labour Members of Parliament had Scottish seats but they could do nothing to halt Thatcherism. SNP MPs mirror that reality.

The big hope is when Cameron holds a referendum over Britain leaving the EEC.  England may well vote yes. Scotland will vote no. We could have a constitutional crisis. I’m sorry to say I was right about the Tory’s winning this election, but less sorry about predicting SNP sweeping Labour aside in Scotland. They got what they deserve. The problem is the Conservatives never seem to get what they deserve. Heads they win. Tails you lose. The games rigged and the poor man is always the loser. Scott Halley has a point. There’s no point in politics. I'm moving my assets to Switzerland where they'll properly appreciate and I may follow on later.

http://unbound.co.uk/books/lily-poole

Comments

Prescient and accurate.

angrycrying

 

That picture up there says so much. This brilliantly written and cuts to the actual problem (s) without distraction. 

 

Good insight into the skewed meritocracy that caused tactical voting to such devastating effect. At least Cameron has no one to hide behind if he goes against his word for an equal society and thank goodness Balls has gone. That was the sweetest victory in a thunderstorm of relentless defeat. Looks like the coast's clear for a nice new reign of terror but I hope there's no referendum coz if the English vote out, the fell be much worse trouble ahead.

 

nose to the grindstone, literally. 

 

My only disappointment is that it is not a hung parliament. If it had been, and if labour and conservative parties refused to negotiate with the SNP (the third largest party) then it would have been a clear indication to any fence-sitters and doubters in Scotland that Westminster has no respect for their democratically voiced opinion. For me, if that had happened it would have been enough to justify proposing another referendum. Something like that may still happen. But for now we are stuck with a conservative government we did not elect and whose main interests lie within London and the south of England.

I'm an English ex-pat living in Aberdeenshire. I voted yes in the referendum and for the SNP on Thursday because I do not believe Westminster can be trusted with Scotlands interests. It does say something when some voters in England where disappointed they could not vote for Nicola Sturgeon. Her sincerity alone showed the other party leaders to be exactly what they are: cheap, untrustworthy, and driven by self-interest. (Actually, strike Nick Clegg from that list. I think he tried to do what he thought was best and then got shafted by the Old Etonian).

Echoes of John Major here. I've been saying for months Cameron would win. The SNP landslide was much more obvious. And SNP stated, which I like to hear, they would not work with a Tory govrenment. It was Labour or bust. Unfortunetly it's bust. Not for SNP for Labour. They'll never again be a party of government. The 59 Scottish seats on which they rely are gone. They may in other elections (if we're not independent get 10) but not enough to stop the continuing Tory juggernaught. This isn't a five-year sentence, but at least a 15 or 20 stretch with no time off for remission. SNP are making noises about what they are going to do. They have no power to make demands. The dismantling of the welfare state (or at least what remains of it) will happen in the usual ways - another scare about it being unaffordable and harbouring that lower class of person- blaming the poor for being poor. Meantime Ashley's shares at Sports Direct jump 25%. He can do what he likes with his workforce. With no union backing, because there are no unions, Labour is hit with a perfect storm matched only by its own imcompetence and alienation from the people who made it working class and something to be proud of. It's a good time to be rich. 

 

A very insightful blog article as usual, which I cannot do any other than agree with on most points. Being English, although feeling British, I feel saddened by the way Scotland seems to be pulling itself inexorably away from the rest of the UK. I hope this does not end up with separation in the end, because after centuries of history I think we belong together and we ought to work well together. The SNP is like the Labour Party on many issues, but unless it manages to form some kind of common ground with left leaning groups such as Labour there will never be any more chances to wrest government from Tory subjection to the dictates of business without consideration for workers/the people. Perhaps if we could somehow miraculously move to some form of proportional representation we will never get progressive government back for the UK as a whole. The left has for now shot itself in the foot again. Nationalism is fine but really its for dreamers and fantasists. United we stand, and divided we fall.

Kurt, for me independence is not about nationalism.  It's about taking a new way of doing things;  the idea that an alteration of circumstance could bring better circumstances than have gone before.  Nationalism is as rubbish as capitalism.  Freedom from the daftness of the past, the stupidity of false promise, misplaced hope and exploited loyalty - that's the rationale.  That's worth it.