Feedback - A Submarine Circus

3 posts / 0 new
Last post
Feedback - A Submarine Circus

All,

I am not sure if anyone has been reading "A Submarine Circus" that I have been writing. If you have read it or would like to read it, I would appreciate some feedback - whether you like the story or simply hate it - any feedback would be appreciated.

I am stuck as to where to go (writer's block or lack of direction). Maybe I'll have to back off the story for a while to get a fresh perspective. I had originally planned one thing, but do not like the way it progresses. Any suggestions, ideas, or helpful hints - on either the writing as it is now or suggestions as to where to go with it would be great. Thank you in advance.

http://www.abctales.com/node/558513

H, I've had a read through the first five or so instalments of 'A Submarine Circus' and a have a few questions / suggestions / ideas, based on what I think you're trying to do. 1. If you're inside of someone's head, they'd better be interesting I'm really quite unsure about the interior dialogue format of the story. A narrator tells us some stuff. Then they tell us some more stuff. Interior narration can work, but it has to be vivid, interesting, and above all give us something that we couldn't have seen other wise. If you restructure all the sentences in the first part of 'A Submarine Circus' and put them in the form of 'he saw', 'he looked', 'he heard', you'll find that nothing really has changed. As a reader, I don't want to hear a characters narration of something, rather than seeing for myself what they see, unless they have some really, really interesting things to say. 2. Other characters Due to the interior narrative of the story, there is no space for interaction with anyone. Whether the characters are figments of a deranged mind or surrealist ghosts, it'd be nice to see interaction rather than just hear about it. 3. What do you want from me? Or rather what does your main character want? Why are they doing stuff? What do they want to happen? You might not write this explicitly into the story, but you should know. What is driving the story on? Are they lonely? Dying? Do they have indigestion? What are they going to do about it? 4. Surrealism in general Surrealism is great. It can be funny, scary and can upend the world. It's a radical strategy. If you decide that anything that can be imagined can happen in your fictional world, why not really push the boat out? These are just thoughts, hope you find them helpful. Cheers, Mark

 

Mark, Thank you for your thoughts and your time. It is greatly appreciated. They've made me think from a different perspective and jostled the numbed synapses a bit. I have redone the first entry to try to cut out the interior dialogue overload and made it third person. I believe I like it better this way - even though it still needs some work. As for the interactions between the characters - I will try to implement something. I had originally intended for the interactions to occur later on when all the characters ended up on the submarine with the main character. But I'm not sure I like my original idea - and per chance is why I am stuck. I will mess around with it some more and try to work in some before they meet. Thank you for your thoughts. They were very helpful. A link to the 3rd person version: http://www.abctales.com/node/558853 Thanks, Harrison O'Hara www.ginotiamain.com

Harrison O'Hara
www.ginotiamain.com

Topic locked