The death of satirical songs

6 posts / 0 new
Last post
The death of satirical songs

I've just been listening to the Monty Python Sings CD and have been blown away yet again by the sheer quality of the writing. Eric Idle is a genius. Listening to it also made me sad, because it seems to me that that that type of writing is a dying art ' no one crafts stupid/satirical/pointless songs anymore and I think we're all the poorer for it. It's a strong British tradition after all ' from Music Hall through Python to Spitting Image.
The humorous song is one of the most simple, direct and easy accessible methods of satire we've ever had, and now it doesn't seem to exist at all. Remember the outcry over men being crucified whilst singing "Always look on the bright side of life"? Or the discussion of Catholic dogma raised by "Every sperm is sacred"? The Tory government of the 80s was repeatedly savaged by Spitting Image songs, and the country felt all the better for it. It seems to me that the 21st century world ' especially Britain ' is full to the rafters with pompous, self serving and hypocritical "personalities' like Blair, Prescott, Bush et al who seem to just swan around impervious to it all, and there is a sore need for any tools we can grasp that would help bring them down a peg or two. The well written, pointed ditty is of the sharpest of those tools and it's a crying shame that it isn't used anymore. Apart from in South Park (thank God for Stone and Parker) the only place comedy writing is even vaguely used (though badly) is in adverts, and that is just a waste.
What I want to know is WHY it has died out? Is it just out of favour? Is it that there is no one capable of writing it anymore? Is there a view that it isn't needed? Or is it just that as a form it is just so looked down on that no one will even countenance the idea that it may be useful?

I wonder if the extreme Moslem brotherhood would like to cast a light on this?

 

Bremner, Bird and Fortune do it at the end of every episode. Chris Morris usually includes them too. There was an outcry when the Brass Eye paedophile special was aired. Added to that, the likes of Blair and Brown are repeatedly 'punctured' by newspaper cartoons, comedy shows and the like, as well as criticised by dozens of columnists. They still swan around because such stuff very rarely has any impact on their political careers, no matter how clever and/or accurate it is. Satire alone just isn't powerful enough to bring its enemies down - the best it can do, usually, is stop us all going mad by allowing us to laugh at the things that are usually so frustratingly rubbish. Outcries and the like may suggest that art can have an impact, but it's usually just the same wedge of the humourless, backwards, and thick as pigshit who feel threatened, and the same dull issues of censorship and responsibility that arise.
This is allied to satire. Maybe it's beyond satire. I rented 'The Times They are a'changing' (Aint that the truth!) by Bob Dylan, from the library. The Lonesome Death Of Hattie Carrol still makes me weep. And William Zantzinger still walks around today. He did six months inside for killing a black woman who had upset him.

 

Perhaps this is why Bush and Blair are not greatly impressed by the growing number of civilian deaths in the Lebanon. Maybe someone could use the stats to write new words to the song "Blow The Man Down." http://www.unknownnews.net/casualties.html
I remember some programme on the Iraq situation ending with Tom Lehrer's Send the Marines. Could've been written yesterday. I agree about Stone and Parker - jaw dropping stuff sometimes but spot on. As for current silly stuff - there's always those two doctors, 'Fitness to Practice.' Probably can't do any better than the Medical Love Song though.
Topic locked