Discordant Apple-Improvement Ideas?
Tue, 2008-05-27 00:55
#1
Discordant Apple-Improvement Ideas?
Apologies for bringing this one up again but it won't stop bugging me :) This time i was wondering if anyone had any ideas or opinions on how i could write this for the better. Sci-fi is not my forte; indeed, this story is my first proper attempt, and i would really like to deviate from historical stuff just this once.
So-thoughts?
http://www.abctales.com/story/jacobea/discordant-apple-chapter-one-edited
My thoughts are that there's not much to say that isn't entirely subjective. The story is a kind of gothic punk science fiction - horror crossover and it's not really my kind of thing. Still, I do remember reading some Piers Anthony when I was a kid which drew heavily on folkloric imagery: werewolves, unicorns and all that so you're not exactly out on a limb.
I wasn't left really caring who or what was in the coffin - perhaps you could give us more of a hint as to what the werewolf is thinking - write it from the werewolf's point of view perhaps. I don't identify with anyone in the story and have to stick through loads of stuff that just establishes again and again that we are in a very different world without finding out much interesting about any characters. Is this a prologue or a true short story?
The first moment that put me off was the flying hearse. I reckon you'd have been better to describe a flying vehicle and then let us find out that it's a hearse: 'the long black grav-car sped....' for example; when they pull the coffin out of the back we'll realise that it's a hearse.
Hope some of this is useful - I'd be happy to discuss the story some more in exchange for a reading and ideas from you about my recent story 'Wodan's Bathhouse'. Deal?