Helen and the Hours of Death by Jack Cade

7 posts / 0 new
Last post
Helen and the Hours of Death by Jack Cade

Jack said he wanted help 'de-creakifying it' so here goes.

I liked it a lot, it felt like a sort of Phillip K Dick does ChickLit thing. The writing, especially the descriptive writing, is fantastic. Anyone who writes lines like 'the second hand which twitched like a beetle on it's back' needs no help from the likes of me.

The story didn't quite come together though, I think basically it wants two things, more of the other Helen, and a better murder (just running away doesn't cut the mustard, she needs to do something).

If it were me writing it, I'd make Helen more interested in the other Helen earlier, trying to discover what was going on, ringing up friends from work, checking her home e-mail account, that sort of thing. George less friendly and more threatening, make it some sort of drug that had to be taken to restore normality, and Helen, our Helen, somehow trick the other Helen into taking it (decant it into a gin bottle). But it ain't me writing it so you're on your own there.

And I don't like the last paragraph, I'd loose that entirely.

Aha! Brill! This is very useful. Thanks, Maddan! I think you've touched on something with a better murder. I've got a problem in that I want to keep her utterly unmalicious, and for it not to occur to her that she'd destroyed this other person until after she'd done it. But as it is, there's no real explanation. I can't bring myself to make George less friendly. Maybe it's just my experience of management and salesmanship, but I find the nonstop friendliness more sinsiter than anything. I'd also like to keep the other Helen in the shadows, so the scope of her personality change is only restricted by the reader's imagination.
I think Dan is spot on. I would raise issue with the Gothic tag Jack pinned to this piece. Of course the genre has evolved from the fainting maidens, ruined castles, long lost evil relatives, and mysterious foreign counts in cloaks that so tightly defined Gothic and ultimately caused its ridicule, but to me this came across more like a ‘Tales of Mystery and Imagination’. I’m not saying that as a bad thing, it’s just that for my tastes it lacks menace, and any Gothic piece still depends upon an otherworldly shadow. That said, what it lacked in menace it recouped in intrigue.
This really did work for me. It reminded me of the days when I worked in a call-centre and felt like two different people. George reminded me of my smiling, bullying, boss and the whole story is surreal. Personally, I wouldn't change it.

Lfuller

The Gothic content is the twinning, the seer/messenger character, the death and the mystery. I didn't study Gothic lit myself, but Brighteyes is doing at the moment, and has told me that these are some of the key elements of the genre, rather than maidens and castles. Agree with you about the 'otherworldly' shadow though. This is what I was aiming for with all the wolves and scarecrows stuff. Cheers, Polidori, and thanks, Queen Elf! Incidentally, apologies that I'm only hanging around on debate/my own threads today, but am at work, and while a comment can be part-written, and then returned to, it's hard to find the space to read anything properly.
I think that this fits in well with the gothic genre, (studied it last year, glad I don't have to do it again) as there is an element of psychological mystery to it. I enjoyed reading this and will be interested to read it again if you do decide to do an edit, I did feel that there was alot squeezed in there and it could perhaps be made longer. I loved the glitter in the pubes reference btw, that's three times in one week!
I was really looking forward to reading this Jack, and it is very good, But i have to agree it actually needs to be longer, i wanted more about the other Helen. I haven't studied gothic literature but the otherwordly thing passed me by until the your comment pointed them out, so maybe they need to be stronger - for the uninitiated. Good stuff, worth some more work to make it sparkle or glitter :) Juliet

Juliet

Topic locked